Supreme Court

Case: 07-0009    
07-0009
01/05/2007
Multidistrict Litigation
IN RE AD VALOREM TAX LITIGATION 
 
Appellate Briefs
Date Event TypeDescriptionRemarksDocument
05/15/2007Multidistrict Litigation supplemental RespondentSupplemental Response of Bexar Appraisal District, et al. (filed by Joseph Longoria)
03/21/2007Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedMovantValero's consolidated reply in support of motion for transfer (filed by Thomas Phillips)
02/13/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentCaldwell County Appraisal District respone to motion for transfer (filed by Judity Hargrove)
02/13/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentVictoria County Appraisal District Response to Motion for Transfer (filed by W. Clayton Cain)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentHidalgo County Appraisal District's Response to Valero's Motion to Transfer (filed by Richard Talbert)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentBexar Appraisal County, Brazoria County Appraisal, Denton County Appraisal, et al's response to motion for transfer (filed by Joseph Longoria)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentHarris County Appraisal District's Response in opposition to motion for transfer (filed by Mario Dell'Osso)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentBrazos County Appraisal District's Response to Motion for Transfer (filed by Jon Miller)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentCalhoun County Appraisal District, McLennan County Appraisal District, and Bell County Appraisal District's response to motion for transfer (filed by Matthew Tepper)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentGalveston Central Appraisal District & Galveston Central Appraisal Review Board's response in opposition to motion for transfer (filed on J.D. Bashline)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentDallas Central Appraisal District's Response in Opposition to Motion for Transfer (filed by Michael Lang)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentJim Wells County Appraisal District's Response to Valero's Motion for Transfer (filed by Tom C. Wheat)
02/09/2007Multidistrict Litigation Filing RespondentLetter filed by Dexter Joyner on behalf of Ft Bend Central Appraisal District
02/09/2007MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondentOn behalf of Jefferson County Appraisal District (filed by Tom Hanna)
01/05/2007Appendix FiledMovantAppendix attached
01/05/2007Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to TransferMovantValero Energy Corporation's Motion for Transfer (filed by Thomas R. Phillips)
Case Events
DateEvent TypeDispositionRemarksDocument
06/26/2007Multidistrict Litigation Motion to Transfer disposedCase denied with opinionJustice Lang delivered the unanimous opinion of the MDL Panel (Justice Peeples not sitting)
Justice Bland sitting pursuant to Tx Gov't Code Section 22.005
05/22/2007Motion for Leave to File Post Submission disposedDeniedValero Energy Corporation's motion for leave to file post-submission brief denied
05/21/2007Motion for leave to file post submission brief Valero Energy Corporation's motion for leave to file post-submission brief (filed by Stephen G. Tipps)
05/17/2007Oral argument  No pdf version of O/A Transcript
05/17/2007Exhibits received Exhibit rec'd
05/15/2007Multidistrict Litigation supplemental  Supplemental Response of Bexar Appraisal District, et al. (filed by Joseph Longoria)
04/16/2007Document received (See Remarks) Hard copies of Unopposed Motion to Postpone Hearing on Motion to Transfer filed by Jefferson County Appraisal District (back dated to 4/13/07)
04/13/2007Motion to postpone submission date disposedFiling dismissed as mootUnopposed motion to postpone hearing on motion to transfer filed by Jefferson County Appraisal District dismissed as moot
04/13/2007Motion to postpone submission date filed Unopposed motion to postpone hearing on motion to transfer filed on behalf of Jefferson County Appraisal District (Amy Keith, atty)
04/13/2007Motion to postpone submission date disposedFiling grantedUnopposed motion to continue oral argument (filed by Bexar Appraisal District, et al.) granted; Oral argument reset for May 17, 2007 @ 10 a.m. in SC Courtroom.  Request for additional time to argue at hearing is denied.
04/12/2007Motion to postpone submission date filed Unopposed motion to continue oral argument & for additional time of Bexar Appraisal District, et al (filed by Joseph Longoria)
04/10/2007Motion to postpone submission date disposedDeniedUnopposed motion to postpone hearing on motion to transfer filed by Caldwell County Appraisal District, et al. denied
04/10/2007Phone call from Clerk's Office Call made to J.D. Bashline and Stephen Tipps regarding motion to postpone.  Panel denied motion.
04/09/2007Motion to postpone submission date filed Unopposed motion to postpone hearing on motion to transfer filed by Caldwell County Appraisal District, et al. (filed by Judith Hargrove)
03/27/2007Letter sent to notice counsel Letter sent to Counsel stating that Justice Peeples has recused himself.  At the request of the Panel & pursuant to Tx Govt Code Section 74.161 & Rule 13.2(a) of Tx Rls of Judicial Administration, the Court appoints Justice Jane Bland of the First Court of Appeals to hear the matter.
03/27/2007Notice setting hearing in Multidistrict Litigation Case Hearing set for 4/20/07 @ 10 a.m. (Justice Peeples not sitting)  Justice Bland sitting by assignment of Chief Justice Jefferson
03/21/2007Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed Valero's consolidated reply in support of motion for transfer (filed by Thomas Phillips)
02/26/2007MET to file reply disposed ofFiling grantedUnopposed m/e/t to file reply in support of motion for transfer granted.  Reply due n/l/t 5:00 p.m. on 3/21/07.
02/20/2007Motion to Extend Time to File Reply filed Valero Energny Corporation's Unopposed m/e/t to file reply in support of motion for transfer (filed by Stephen Tipps)
02/20/2007Amended Appendix filed Valero Energy Corp's amended appendix (filed by Allyson Ho)
02/13/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Caldwell County Appraisal District respone to motion for transfer (filed by Judity Hargrove)
02/13/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Victoria County Appraisal District Response to Motion for Transfer (filed by W. Clayton Cain)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Hidalgo County Appraisal District's Response to Valero's Motion to Transfer (filed by Richard Talbert)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Bexar Appraisal County, Brazoria County Appraisal, Denton County Appraisal, et al's response to motion for transfer (filed by Joseph Longoria)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Harris County Appraisal District's Response in opposition to motion for transfer (filed by Mario Dell'Osso)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Brazos County Appraisal District's Response to Motion for Transfer (filed by Jon Miller)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Calhoun County Appraisal District, McLennan County Appraisal District, and Bell County Appraisal District's response to motion for transfer (filed by Matthew Tepper)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Galveston Central Appraisal District & Galveston Central Appraisal Review Board's response in opposition to motion for transfer (filed on J.D. Bashline)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Dallas Central Appraisal District's Response in Opposition to Motion for Transfer (filed by Michael Lang)
02/12/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer Jim Wells County Appraisal District's Response to Valero's Motion for Transfer (filed by Tom C. Wheat)
02/09/2007Multidistrict Litigation Filing  Letter filed by Dexter Joyner on behalf of Ft Bend Central Appraisal District
02/09/2007MDL Response to Motion for Transfer On behalf of Jefferson County Appraisal District (filed by Tom Hanna)
01/26/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Response disposedFiling grantedRsp's m/e/t to file response to motion for transfer granted.  Response due n/l/t 5:00 p.m. on 2/9/07.
01/25/2007Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Agreed m/e/t to file reply to motion to transfer (filed by J.D. Bashline)
01/05/2007Appendix Filed Appendix attached
01/05/2007Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to Transfer Valero Energy Corporation's Motion for Transfer (filed by Thomas R. Phillips)
Calendars
Set DateCalendar TypeReason SetRemarks
No Calendar.
Parties
PartyPartyTypeRepresentative
GALVESTON CENTRAL APPRAISAL DIRespondentMr. J.D. Bashline
VALERO ENERGY CORPORATIONMovantMr. Stephen G. Tipps
Mr. Thomas R. Phillips
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information
 
 
 
 
 
 

To view or print PDF files you must have the Adobe Acrobat® reader. This software may be obtained without charge from Adobe. Download the reader from the Adobe Web site